PS615Whole School Issues Journal
CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
Observe a class for one lesson, using one of the observation activities given (see relevant sheets). Record your observations below, using the headings from the observation sheets as a guide.
I observed a mixed-ability Year 10, coursework-focused lesson that was linked to previous lessons in a bid to continue drafting a piece of commentary-style coursework essay on a piece of pre-1914 poetry “The Charge Of The Light Brigade”. There were 24 pupils in the class, 16 of whom were male.
At the start of the lesson, the teacher used the board to revisit key ideas or themes of the poem that would be essential to pupils successfully completing the coursework essay. This was done through open questioning, in a whole-class context, enforcing a hands-up rule and with pupils being awarded appropriate praise for useful contributions and their ideas being displayed on the board. This helped to maintain positive teacher-pupil relationships.
After this starter activity, pupils were verbally set the task of continuing with their essay individually. The individual nature of the task was firmly made explicit with the teacher reminding pupils of the need for quiet individual work but factors contributed to a high proportion of pupils to become off task, prompting constant intervention by the classroom teacher. Learning objectives were not clearly displayed or made verbally explicit at the start of the lesson, while the layout of the room, an ineffective seating plan and the positioning of the teacher somewhat contributed to certain pupils becoming off-task.
The girls in the room, outnumbered by the boisterous boys, were sat in a ‘female ghetto’ on the left hand side of the classroom, on two ‘islands’ of desks, each seating four pupils, as illustrated in the picture above. These islands meant that pupils were working in close proximity to each other, creating an environment that may have had an adverse effect in terms of behaviour on an individual writing task.
The girls would be singled out for praise for their diligence by the female teacher, on the whole, with clusters of unruly boys being disciplined and indeed dismantled during the course of the lesson in a bid to stem further low-level disruptive behaviour. The difference in the nature and amount of teacher interaction between the two genders was shaped by the behaviour and application demonstrated by both boys and girls. Whereas girls asked more questions regarding the task and required more teacher support in their learning, many boys posed classroom management issues through their disruptive behaviour.
There was no differentiation in terms of printed resources or task, with all pupils being issued the Pre-1914 Poetry Anthology at the beginning of the lesson and this being the only resource, apart from the board, that pupils would all use to continue their writing task from the previous lesson.
In terms of supporting pupils learning, the teacher was on hand to respond to pupils’ questions about the poem, but the lesson was dominated by the teacher having to continually address low-level disruptive behaviour.
The lack of an effective starter activity, the discussion of learning objectives or even the calling of a register was apparent and this only contributed to a slow start to the lesson where pupils were not entirely focused. In order to attempt to restore a positive learning environment during the writing task, the teacher moved certain disruptive pupils and reminded the whole class about the need for concentration and application numerous times, ensuring that those who were particularly disruptive lost their breaktime which immediately followed the lesson. The writing task lasted until the bell sounded for break, with no plenary being used to reinforce any aspect of the poem or activity.
I decided to discuss this lesson with my current mentor and reflect on what can be learned in terms of classroom management issues with a view towards progressing towards various Qualifying To Teach standards.
Record your notes of the school-based discussion session below:
In terms of evaluating this lesson, both myself and my mentor agreed that there were many aspects of classroom management that could be considered. It is clear that a number of aspects of the lesson can be evaluated and reflected upon in order to minimize the low-level disruption that provided an obstacle to successful learning.
My mentor commented that, from the outset, a seating plan, taking into account many factors should be implemented to minimize behavioural issues. This could be also be combated by ensuring that the layout of the room is suitable for the lessons activities. In this lesson, the desks were positioned in a way that was ideal for group work rather than individual writing tasks - with the desks arranged in islands seating four, rather than the more traditional layout seating two in rows. The latter may have been a more practical approach due to the nature of the task in the lesson.
In terms of the starter activity, my mentor commented that this could have been different, with a paired brainstorming activity around an aspect of the poem possibly preparing the pupils better for the lesson. Pair work would certainly have suited the layout of the desks, but issues could possibly arise of certain pupils refusing to work with others within a seating plan.
Disciplining pupils, in a variety of ways, is a skill in itself. In this instance, low-level disruption hindered the learning of pupils and could have been minimized through effective strategies which have already been mentioned. To be effective, my mentor commented, sanctions must be explicit and followed through and, in this case, when sanctions were imposed, to an extent, some low-level disruption was quashed. However, this situation could have been somewhat avoided through effective planning, with more structure to the lesson.
The individual writing task was possibly too long, my mentor commented, with pupils being expected to concentrate for an ambitious length of time. This could have been shortened by the effective use of a plenary to consolidate pupils’ knowledge and understanding.
A plenary is essential to the lesson structure in terms of assessing how well pupils are progressing. In this instance, a short competitive quiz on aspects of the poem may have been useful to end the lesson on a positive note, while checking for knowledge and understanding.
In conclusion, it is important to be reflective about classroom management issues and to think critically and carefully about one’s approaches. Strategies for minimising pupil misbehaviour are varied and begin with the careful planning of the lesson, taking into account a variety of factors as discussed.
EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES
You should complete ONE of the tasks given below:
A. Choose one of the case studies given (see end of booklet) and consider how you would address the issues which arise. You may wish to discuss available options with members of school staff. Discussion should focus upon identification of the issues involved and upon strategies which might be employed.
B. Observe pupil activity in the playground and break or lunchtime. It is important to be unobtrusive!
Who groups with whom?
What do the boys do?
What do the girls do?
Who uses the space?
What types of activity go on? Who is involved?
If there are benches/seats who uses them?
What kinds of conversation take place? Furtive? Loud? What body language?
Who invades others’ space?
Is there physical contact? What sort?
Are there particular incidents ? e.g. bullying. Is it dealt with? How?
Record your own reactions to the case study material (if you have chosen A) or your observations (if you have chosen B) below.
Case Study B
In discussion with my current mentor, what was first agreed is that the behaviour of the member of staff concerned is absolutely unacceptable on a number of levels. Not only has the member of staff blindly presumed that the three black youngsters are outside the Headteacher’s office due to a disciplinary matter, which could not even be the case, the member of staff has also made completely inappropriate comments to another teacher simply because of the colour of their skin. In thinking and expressing themselves in this way, the member of staff has demonstrated both ignorance and racism, not only towards pupils indirectly, but more directly towards another member of staff at the school. Both instances, in prejudging pupils and staff have no place in the modern 21st century British school.
All teachers need to be aware of the legislation with regard to the equal opportunities since this has a direct impact on the school’s role as a provider and an employer. The Race Relations Act 1976 (and amended by the Race Relations Act 2000) places a new statutory duty on pubic authorities to promote race equality. The aims of this a threefold: to eliminate unlawful race discrimination, to promote equality of opportunity and to promote good relations between people from different racial groups. The wider political task is to create and enforce legislation against unfair discrimination, both direct and indirect, in all major areas of social life, particularly in employment. (Richardson and Wood 1999).
The Act is designed to assist schools in promoting a proactive approach which builds race equality into the mainstream of schools and their existing mechanisms. This is manifested through a requirement for schools to prepare and maintain a written Race Equality Policy. This policy must also link with other policies and it’s impact on staff, students and parents from different racial groups must be monitored and evaluated.
Research has indicated that racial harassment in schools is a common part of a student’s everyday experience. Often, this type of harassment is not regarded as a problem because there are few complaints. The reasons for this may be that victims believe no action will be taken, are too embarrassed to make a complaint or fear reprisals for making a complaint. (Ellis et al 2002) In reality, it was agreed that it could be a combination of these factors.
Possible situations arising from possible complaints about this member of staff’s ignorance could be a breakdown in relations between certain members of staff with disciplinary issues following. One solution, in terms of senior management, could be to monitor this member of staff’s work with ethnic minorities within the school environment to ascertain whether they are treated any differently.
In 21st century Britain, teachers to be awarded QTS are required to recognize and respond effectively to equal opportunities issues as they arise, including by challenging stereotyped views, and by challenging bullying or harassment, following relevant policies and procedures (Dfes S3.3.14). This is extremely important in the political context of an ever-changing world, particularly in an area of the country which has recently experienced the ugly face of violent race relation problems both my current mentor and myself agreed.
SPECIAL EDUCATIONAL NEEDS
Using the guidance at the back of the booklet record your findings below
1. Defining Special Educational Needs
All students, irrespective of ability or disability, have an equal right to a broad and balanced curriculum which meets their needs, states the school’s SEN policy. At the Heartlands High School the SENCO believes that all teachers are teachers of students with special educational needs and teaching such students is therefore a whole school responsibility.
The aim of this policy is to meet the needs of all students with special educational needs to enable them to achieve their full potential, intellectually, spiritually, socially, emotionally and physically. The school aims to recognise and provide equality of access and inclusion to the curriculum for all students and value the contribution they make to the life of the school.
The school’s SEN policy recognises that the importance of early identification and assessment for any students who may have special educational needs cannot be over-emphasised. This was reinforced by the SENCO in discussion. The earlier action is taken, the quicker appropriate help can be provided without unduly disrupting the organisation of the school, and the more responsive the student is likely to be, it was agreed.
In addition to making use of information passed-on from primary schools, Heartlands High uses evidence from teacher observation and assessment their performance against the level descriptions within the National Curriculum at the end of a key stage; their progress against the objectives specified in the National Literacy and Numeracy Frameworks for teaching; standardised screening or assessment tests.
The school’s staff are also open and responsive to any expressions of concerns by parents or carers and take into account any information which they may provide for the school. In addition, other professionals working within the school, such as members of external support services or Connexions Personal Advisers, may become aware of issues relating to individual students and the school will be proactive in responding to their concerns.
The Education Act 1996, Section 312 says that a student has special educational needs if they have a learning difficulty which calls for special educational provision to be made for them. This is clearly outlined and defined in the SEN policy which is available to all staff, with a copy remaining in the staffroom for reference.
The attached Appendix 1 from the school’s SEN policy is extracted from the Revised Code of Practice (Dfes 2001) is available to all staff, defining common types of SEN to make identification in pupils easier.
2. Managing Special Educational Needs
At The Heartlands High School the Governing Body appoints, annually, a committee of governors to take a particular interest in and closely monitor the school’s work on behalf of students with special educational needs. This committee also has the responsibility for reviewing the school’s SEN policy on an annual basis. The Headteacher has responsibility for the day-to-day management of all aspects of the school including the provision for students with special educational needs. She keeps the Governing Body fully informed about all issues related to special educational needs. At the same time she works closely with the school’s SEN co-ordinator. The Headteacher is responsible for contacting the LEA when it is felt that a statutory assessment should be made. All teaching and non-teaching staff should be fully aware of the school’s procedures for identifying, assessing and making provision for students with special educational needs. At all stages, the subject teacher is responsible for planning the pupils’ work and ensuring his/her progress. At School Action and School Action Plus stages, subject teachers collaborate with the SENCO and support services as appropriate. The SENCO, is responsible for working closely with the Headteacher and senior management and with their fellow teachers for determining the strategic development of the SEN policy and provision. The SENCO has responsibility for both the day-to-day operations of the SEN policy and for co-ordinating provision for students with special educational needs particularly through School Action and School Action Plus stages.
After initially collaborating with other staff and identifying the special educational needs of the child, completing an IEP and implementing the School Action stage through the setting of short-term targets in report form (see Appendix 2), the SENCO is responsible for monitoring and reviews the pupils progress towards their personal targets with help from different subject tutors. All these daily reports are completed by the pupils’ subject tutors and regularly reviewed at a specific time by the SENCO in conjunction with the pupil involved. An example of a daily report form from a pupil in my form at Heartlands is provided as Appendix 2.
The SENCO ensures that all staff are aware of pupils IEPs and ensures that staff know where to find SEN information on pupils in their classes and how to provide support. The SENCO regularly liaises with subject teachers to discuss the progress of individuals and comments or grades on daily report forms. All students with SEN statements are set short-term targets which are first discussed, then set by the SENCO and agreed by the pupil. These are outlined in the daily report form, taken by pupils to each lesson including registration (see Appendix 2). These targets and strategies to help pupils meet them are also set out in the IEP. The school follows the procedures set out in the SEN Code of Practice 2001 when carrying out annual reviews for students with statements of special need. The IEP, as a basis for helping the individual pupil, only records the things which are additional to or different from the normal, differentiated curriculum provision. While the SENCO may be responsible for actually defining the type of SEN and pointing subject teachers in the direction of a pupil's IEPs, the delivery of an IEP is the responsibility of the subject teacher.
The IEP is discussed with the student and the parents and is reviewed at least twice yearly. Where possible, one of these reviews will take place between the SENCO and the parents and student at a scheduled Parents’ Evening and the other will take place as a ‘private’ meeting at which a member of the student’s pastoral team will be invited to attend in addition to the SENCO.
The SENCO has expressed that co-operation from subject teachers in accurately completing the daily report forms is crucial in terms of monitoring and reporting on pupils progress. Reviews can only be conducted effectively if subject teachers provide useful, detailed information about the individual pupil. Review meetings can have several outcomes: it may result in a decision being taken as to whether good progress has been made with the student no longer requiring additional support and can be taken off the School Action stage; it may be that some progress has been made, the support being given is appropriate and will continue in the same form until the next review (student continues at School Action stage); it may be that some progress has been made, but the support needs to be amended and the student will still remain at the School Action stage, or little or no progress has been made, the level of support needs to be increased and consideration needs to be given to moving the student to School Action Plus stage.
At The Heartlands High School, the triggers for further intervention through the School Action Plus stage are underpinned by evidence that, despite receiving an individualised programme and/or concentrated support, the student continues to make little or no progress in specific areas over a long period; or continues working at National Curriculum levels substantially below that expected of students of a similar age; or continues to have difficulty in developing literacy and numeracy skills; or has emotional or behavioural difficulties which substantially and regularly interfere with their own learning or that of the class group, despite having an individualised behaviour management programme; or has sensory or physical needs, and requires specialist equipment or regular advice or visits, providing direct intervention to the student or advice to the staff, by a specialist service; or has ongoing communication or interaction difficulties that impede the development of social relationships and cause substantial barriers to learning.
At the stage of School Action Plus, The Heartlands High School consults specialists when taking action on behalf of a student.
The staff, from external support services, advise on new and appropriate targets for the student’s IEP and on accompanying strategies. They may also be asked to provide additional specialist assessment that can inform planning and the measurement of a student’s progress.
The resulting updated IEP for the student will set out new strategies for supporting the student’s progress. Although developed with the help of external specialists, the strategies specified in the IEP are usually implemented, at least in part and as far as possible, in the normal classroom setting. Delivery of the IEP is again be the responsibility of the subject teachers, with the SENCO monitoring intensely. At the stage of School Action Plus students’ IEPs are reviewed on a termly basis.
The outcome of the review meetings results in a decision being taken as to whether good progress has been made, some progress has been made or little or no progress has been made, meaning the level of support needs to be increased and consideration needs to be given to referring the student for statutory assessment by the LEA.
Concentrated individual support for pupils need not necessarily mean additional adult input into the class to provide one-to-one tuition for a student, however, or even pupils being withdrawn from classes. Other alternative approaches might be to consider the provision of different learning materials or specialist equipment, staff training aimed at the introduction of more effective teaching strategies or obtaining specialist advice from external agencies. The SENCO expressed that a shortage in support staff at the school is leading to less in-class one-to-one tuition. The appointment of another support staff, which took place in mid-March 2006, was welcomed by the SENCO as it meant that more one-to one in-class tuition could be provided for pupils. The new member of staff was also an Urdu speaker which meant that he could value the mother tongue of many pupils with special educational needs of Pakistani origin.
Defining whether a pupil has special educational needs or English language issues is important. Kyricaou has stated that difficulties in approaching tasks and an inability to do the work set contribute to pupil misbehaviour. Therefore, the link between EAL pupils and SEN is somewhat complex. The SENCO has discussed the difficulty in identifying SEN issues in pupils with EAL needs. There is some definite correlation between the two areas though and the SENCO has stressed the importance of identifying an individual pupils needs as early as possible. Premature re-integration into mainstream lessons for newly arrived pupils could lead to behavioural issues, for example, but problems with pupils’ behaviour after successful integration may imply some type of special educational need. It is anticipated that these would endeavour to be identified early though, during the induction process, the SENCO added.
Geraldine Price states in Ellis et al 2002, details the transition from segregation to integration to inclusion in SEN practice. These stages somewhat embody the philosophical, sociological and political changes throughout the years, she argues. Since the 1981 Education Act, integrating and including pupils with SEN has become a prominent feature with these pupils being given the opportunity to participate in the wider context of mainstream school life. At Heartlands school, while a policy of inclusion and integration is dominant, segregation is sometimes deemed necessary for a period of time depending on the individual pupils circumstances. During this period of segregation, pupils work with the SENCO or an LSA to work on basic skills, such as phonics and numeracy.
Pupils with SEN would sometimes be withdrawn from my lessons with staff being notified in morning briefing by the SENCO. These irregular, sporadic withdrawals, usually because of outstanding behavioural issues dominating their daily report forms over a short period of time, and possibly in subjects other than English, led to some pupils missing crucial lessons within a scheme of work around a particular topic, which they may have been progressing quite well in. Pupils would then return to my English class behind in their work compared to their peers and in need of intensive support to avoid the frustration and consequent dip in behaviour arising from feeling out of sync with their peers in terms of progress towards a project. In cases where this happened, with Year 8 and Year 10 pupils, these learners missed crucial lessons towards an assessed piece of work, which undoubtedly has an impact in terms of assessment. How much of an impact would depend on the level of individual support given to the pupil on return to the lesson. In my experience, LSAs were not available, therefore putting extra demands on the subject teacher to significantly differentiate lessons. This situation requires that subject teachers provide structure, staged support, modeled tasks and extra guidance to give these pupils the same learning opportunities as their peers.
3. Special Educational Needs in Your Subject Area
It is imperative that English teachers provide, not only a fully inclusive curriculum, but differentiate their teaching in a variety of ways to accommodate pupils with special educational needs. Discussions with my mentors have centred around the different techniques used to include all pupils such as differentiating questions or tasks, giving particular support or stimulus where it is warranted, and adapting texts such as Shakespeare’s plays which some pupils find somewhat inaccessible. There were also discussions about how centrally important it is to make lessons interesting and engaging in order for all pupils to successfully relate to ideas and concepts explored within aspects of the English curriculum in both school experiences.
Nicola Grove (1998) writes that those pupils with special educational needs may still engage with issues that are at the heart of stories, plays and poems, even if it means that little conventional reading or writing is achieved. Indeed, Clarke et al (2004) continues in this vein by stating that while SEN pupils might not grasp each nuance of meaning of every word in the soliloquies of Act 1 in Macbeth, for example, they can feel how his mind is at war with himself if the material is approached in a stimulating manner. Although including SEN pupils in aspects of central significance in Macbeth is something that teachers do in almost every comprehensive school, it highlights the importance in teachers thinking carefully about their approaches towards ‘less accessible’ material in the syllabus. It is important that English teachers set suitable learning challenges, maintaining high standards and making professional judgments about what are realistic and achievable targets on an individual basis and for the whole group.
4. Adapting Teaching for Special Educational Needs
In terms of adapting English teaching to include all pupils, differentiation is the key. If a child cannot learn the way you teach, you must teach the way he or she learns (Chasty 1990). It is important to create an inclusive learning environment in the classroom and ensuring that barriers to learning are minimised. This can be done in a variety of ways as discussed with my mentor and the SENCO. Considering the variety of SEN categories, planning differentiated work may appear daunting but it is important to be familiar with any IEPs of pupils within the English classroom and take this into account when planning lessons, let alone delivering them and responding to the many different situations which could arise.
Providing a multisensory environment, giving careful consideration to the fact that pupils learn in different way, is vital when planning lessons. A combination of visual, auditory and kinaesthetic activities would tap into as many of these senses as possible, giving pupils more opportunity to succeed in lessons. Structure and staged support break down the process of learning and allow the teacher to consider differentiating basic knowledge from more in-depth knowledge in terms of tasks and activities. This is important to build confidence and skills. Examining what a pupil can already do, and using this knowledge as a springboard will allow the learner to feel secure in the initial stages of learning a new concept. Targeted praise is also an essential tool to increase motivation, but pupils must be made explicitly aware of which skill they have used to good effect. Letting pupils know what they have done which is good and how they have done it is of high importance. This will help students become more metacognitively aware and translate skills to new learning situations.
Planning for the effective deployment of LSAs may be another option for English teachers, circumstances permitting. This is a Qualifying To Teach Standard and (S1.6) it is important though that these support staff are used in an effective manner to enhance the learning of the pupils they work with, developing a students independence and not providing a culture of dependency (Ellis et al 2002). Providing the LSAs with copies of pupils IEPs may prove practical too before working on an individual level with the pupil concerned.
Many pupils with special educational needs have distinct problems with some of the main components of lessons, including verbal instructions, written instructions, reading and writing. It is vital that teachers be reflective about their practices when considering this. The timing of verbal instructions, for example, needs careful consideration when working with pupils with special educational needs. These pupils often tire easily in lessons and lose focus, particularly in the marathon 70-minute lessons at the Heartlands school. Providing alternative formats to verbal instructions, such as using the IAW to display them via PowerPoint or setting them on handouts, will appeal to pupils with different learning styles. If all-important instructions are only given to pupils via one channel, this somewhat isolates those who have may for example have listening problems or whose reading skills may be weak. It is crucial therefore to have a combination of these channels in order to maximise understanding. Keeping the instructions clear and simple will only help pupils to respond successfully. Those with language processing difficulties will struggle if instructions are unnecessarily complex r if there are too many instructions given at one time.
Worksheet production formed the basis of a discussion with the SENCO at the school after an observed lesson, with font size becoming a particular area for discussion. The SENCO stressed that SEN pupils experience difficulties when accessing texts and worksheets and it is fundamental that when producing worksheets this is taken into account. It is therefore recommended to use the ‘Comic Sans’ font, with 14 as the minimum font size. Key vocabulary or instructions should also be in bold, ensuring that those with hesitant reading skills can be taught to skim more effectively (Ellis et al 2002). The use of colour, pictures and text boxes can also add to the effectiveness of a worksheet to help pupils access the task initially it was agreed in discussion.
In terms of actually completing written tasks, which many SEN pupils struggle with, guided practice and modeling are two practical ways to scaffold pupils learning. Writing frames are particularly useful in English lessons, with key words, starter sentences or gap-filling exercises are ways of developing and enhancing writing skills. These are a means to an end, however, and pupils should not become accustomed to these as this could somewhat contribute to a culture of dependency.
Taking into account all of these concepts when working with SEN pupils will contribute to a more positive learning environment must this must be reinforced with effective management of the classroom so that opportunities for poor or unacceptable behaviour are minimized. Pupils who find it difficult to concentrate for periods of time, who cannot seem to remain still or in their seat, who are verbally or physically abusive to their peers or the teacher or whose behaviour is considered anti-social soak up a considerable amount of teachers’ time and energy. In discussion with my mentor and the SENCO, it was agreed that it is important to be explicit in classroom ground rules but also to demonstrate some flexibility on an individual level to a certain extent, while remaining consistent with regard to disruptive behaviour. Non-invasive, non-retaliatory action by the teacher when confronted with challenging behaviour can be most effective it seems in my own experience with SEN pupils, a sentiment that was reinforced by the SENCO.
To attain QTS, trainee teachers must demonstrate that they can differentiate effectively (S3.3.4), setting and reinforcing high expectations of behaviour (S3.3.9) and understanding their responsibilities under the SEN Code of Practice (S2.6). Therefore, a profound knowledge of SEN issues can only serve a trainee teacher well when preparing and delivering lessons.
ASSESSMENT
You should:
1. Find out about and report back on the assessment procedures within your own department including the link between assessment, recording and reporting. Bring linked evidence of all three.
2. Describe and evaluate the assessment strategies you have employed in
your own teaching.
3. Bring a completed end of year report form for two different pupils, preferably one Key Stage 3 and one Key Stage 4. Bring a pastoral report from your tutor group.
Record your notes of the school-based discussion below:
1. It is imperative that teachers use assessment strategies to evaluate pupil progress and improve their own planning and teaching while giving feedback and involving pupils in reflection, evaluating and improving their own performance will only have a beneficial effect.
My mentor stressed that involving pupils fully in assessment procedures was of high importance. Assessment criteria within the English department is made explicit to pupils in a variety of ways with learners being made aware of how their work will be graded and marked at the Heartlands school. The department marks formatively and summatively for accuracy and composition in Key Stage 3 and 4 with a particular focus on the literacy priorities of spelling, punctuation and paragraphing. Assessment of learning seems to be dominant practice, although members of the department are increasingly using assessment for learning techniques on a regular basis. Homework is set once a week during Key Stage 3 on a specific day and comprises of booklets outside the scheme of work, focusing on literacy priorities which enables teachers to assess where pupils are and what they need to progress. In Key Stage 4, homework is linked intrinsically to schemes of work with pupils completing homework tasks to consolidate class work.
Peer and self-assessment practices are steadily increasing due to the departments redrafting policy with the head of department monitoring closely. Teachers note when these assessment techniques are used and this information is reported to the Head of Department periodically. Indeed, involving pupils as much as possible in the assessment process and the impact that this can have on motivation and self-esteem are highlighted by Black and William (1998) in Assessment For Learnng: Inside The Black Box.
Each piece of work is also awarded an Effort Grade from A-D that is designed to increase motivation, making pupils aware of the department’s expectations and providing information for the setting of future targets. The head of department is currently toying with the idea of “Three Stars and a Wish” technique, which aims to give pupils feedback on three features they have excelled in for a piece of work and one aspect they could improve upon. Effectively recording all this data is the key to teachers effectively reporting on pupils’ progress to parents in written form or orally on a ‘review day’ and it is important that teachers have a mark book as the basis for reporting this data. This enables teachers to build a picture of pupils current achievements derived from information gathered over a period of time in order to set future targets. (Harlen, Gipps, Broadfoot and Nuttall 1994) It is estimated by my mentor that exercise books are marked on a weekly basis, with marking regularly inspected by the head of department and the headteacher while the department is pursuing a policy of marking only in green pen currently. Clarke et al (2004) states that the marking of pupils work in English should be positive not negative and respectful not dismissive. The department implements this with a sensitive approach for marking being set out in the guidelines given to English teachers.
My mentor stated that assessment is explained to pupils in a variety of ways. Pupils are provided with a breakdown of effort grades used across the department that are attached to their exercise books. In the English corridor on the fourth floor, a large display outlines to pupils how their work in the subject will be marked. These posters are also visible in all English classrooms for pupils to refer to in lessons. As well as verbally outlining their expectations in terms of assessment during lessons, teachers across the department make learning objectives explicit through encouraging pupils to copy the objectives from the board, explaining them in detail to learners. This provides pupils with a structure and routine to lessons in terms of assessment expectations, making them active participants rather than passive recipients and helps the teacher to track progress and give a clear focus for feedback and marking.
Each half term, the department attempts to give each pupil a National Curriculum Level and my mentor stressed the importance of making pupils aware which level they are currently working at and, just as importantly, how they need to improve to progress to the next National Curriculum level.
At Key Stage 4, coursework and examination objectives need to be adhered to when marking the mountain of coursework created by pupils. Other members of the department moderate pupils work so that at least two different teachers have considered the pupils efforts in conjunction with the relevant assessment criteria for GCSE. This process, which I have been involved in, is useful for trainee teachers to learn about this type of summative assessment.
Most assessment within the department predominantly centres around writing tasks it seems. The importance of speaking and listening, and the assessment of this aspect of the curriculum must not be ignored however as my mentor commented.
2. My own assessment strategies are somewhat meticulous and used to influence the planning of future activities, in order to identify collective and individual weaknesses that need to be addressed. Formative assessment strategies are designed and implemented in order to produce effective periodical reporting. A detailed weekly record of pupils performance and effort through written work and, importantly, speaking and listening contributions is recorded as well as attendance through the calling of a register at the start of each lesson. This provides me with detailed information on how pupils perform in certain tasks, giving me an outline of their strengths and weaknesses which can be then be reported in order to help pupils development in terms of identifying areas for improvement with a view to attaining higher National Curriculum levels.
Books are marked in a system and pupils are made explicitly aware of when their books are marked. The books of each group are marked on a particular day according to the schedule of their lessons. For example, Year 10’s books who I see every Tuesday, Thursday and Friday are marked on Mondays, while Year 7’s books who I teach on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays are marked on Thursdays or Fridays. This system allows me to review and mark their books at the end of a weekly series of lessons and set personal learning targets (PLT) for the forthcoming week, which the pupils will receive on their first lesson back after the weekend. These PLT could be focused on a variety of areas: from issues of presentation or grammar, to spellings and effort. The aim of this is to promote a culture of shared responsibility for learning.
Should pupils demonstrate that they have met a PLT in their subsequent work, such as for example if a PLT had been set to improve presentation by underlining headings and the pupil implemented this in their next piece of work, a very positive comment would be put in their book, and rewarded and recorded with an effort grade of A. Weekly effort grades encompass not only class work but also class contributions and behaviour and are written in pupils books, while their weekly performance, out of five, is recorded only.
My mentors have stressed the importance of positive feedback in pupils’ books and I have pursued this path in my marking. The QCA states that ‘teachers should be aware of the impact that comments, marks, and grades can have on learners’ confidence and enthusiasm and should be as constructive as possible in the feedback that they give.’ (Afl 10 principles)
Departmental policy has ensured that all marking is done in green pen at Heartlands. This is different to my previous school where red pen was acceptable. In conversation with my current mentor, it was mentioned that the department decided to implement this policy to possibly increase motivation but no evidence on whether this has any motivational effect was provided by the department. Through independent research in this area, I found some teachers' blogs who had made a permanent pedagogical shift and discarded their red pen (http://www.teachandlearn.ca/blog/). Other articles online seem to critcise the practice as "politically correct" and "trendy". However, Penny Penn-Howard, head of school improvement for Sandwell Council, states on the BBC New website: "The colour of the pen used for marking is not greatly significant except that the red pen has negative connotations and can be seen as a negative approach to improving pupils' work. (BBC News Online) Again, I could find no hard, colour-oriented psychological evidence that it improves pupils motivation but if it were to only slightly contribute to a more positive learning environment, marking in green pens would become everyday practice.He
The system also affords me time in my planning to build any universal mistakes, such as when a number of pupils had not used ‘your’ and ‘you’re’ in the correct way in a piece of writing, into subsequent lessons. These mistakes can then be concentrated on in either one or both of the ‘starter to make you smarter’ tasks of the weeks lessons and the reasons for the particular task being made explicit to the learners. The information, therefore, gained from assessing pupils’ work can be used to shape the activities in the teaching and learning process towards S3.2.1, S3.2.6.
This assessment for learning-inspired system is central to classroom practice and approached in a sensitive, whole class way. No individual errors are highlighted in front of the group and it is explicitly explained to pupils that in order to climb up through the National Curriculum levels they need a ladder and completing and reflecting on these activities can provide them with the rungs to progress.
The final lesson of the weekly series concentrates on the class ‘spelling review’ – a less conventional starter. It is made explicitly clear to pupils that the ‘spelling review’ is a weekly event and that all the words will be taken from ones misspelled in the previous weeks work and set as PLT in various pupils books. The class are made aware that this is designed to not only improve their spelling but also their independent learning by encouraging them to take note and meet their PLT by spelling the previously misspelled word correctly in the review. Pupils quickly settle into a routine with this weekly event. My previous sub-mentor stressed the importance of having a routine structure to individual lessons and sequences so that pupils know what to expect and this sentiment is echoed by Chris Kyriacou in his book “Effective Teaching In Schools”.
The review is peer marked, with books swapped and any corrections written by the side by their peer. Spelling scores (always out of ten) are recorded weekly, with a class average for the week determined also. This enables me to grade pupils in terms of spelling ability, which is useful for effective reporting and reflecting on my teaching techniques or approaches in order to improve teaching and learning.
For example, on a half-termly average, boys in my year 8 class were consistently the lowest spellers in the class. As an experiment, I tried to implement a further system to improve spelling across the class but also trying to focus on improving the performance of those who time and again perform poorly. The average spelling score for each pupil was calculated for the half-term and pupils were put into one of six bands. Band 1 was those pupils who were consistently the highest scoring spellers, with the bands continuing in ranked spelling ability, and Band 6 therefore containing those who performed most poorly over the period. I then took a pupil from each Band to create a ‘spelling team’. Each team therefore contained six members, all of different, graded abilities in terms of spelling. Each team was given a name (of a famous film director such as Capra or Spielberg, for example) and the ‘Band 6’ member of the team appointed the Team Captain. Giving these pupils this responsibility of being Team Captain is designed to further engage them in the spelling learning process and give them motivation for them to improve their own performance so that their team can win the weekly team spelling competition. The winning team is announced at the start of the first lesson of the week. Team members scores are added together and their team being given a final total. The team with the highest total is the winner and receives 1 point in the ‘Spelling Premiership’. It is hoped that this competitive team element to spelling will motivate all pupils, especially boys who are consistently the lowest scoring, to improve their performances. This will continue after Easter until the end of my second school experience and demonstrates my determination to improve my own teaching by evaluating strategies (S1.7).
I have also used peer assessment in project work as part of the department’s redrafting process. Called ‘Rate Your Mate’, the tasks required pupils to mark their peers work for spelling, detail, coherence, and style, with positive comments encouraged. Pupils responded well to these tasks and it helped them to consider their own work when redrafting. “Peer assessment is uniquely valuable because pupils may accept, from one another, criticism of their work…the interchange will be in a language that pupils themselves understand by taking on roles of teacher and learner” (Black et al 2002)
Separate summative marks are recorded for pupils’ weekly homework tasks in Key Stage 3. This allows me to correlate their effort in homework with assessment of their work in the classroom. From record keeping, predominantly those pupils that perform well in class tasks usually perform equally as well in homework. Anomalies in the data may provide the basis for future target setting in the reporting procedure too. For example, if a pupil is performing well in class tasks but their homework is consistently not the same standard, this may arouse concern, which could then be effectively reported both to the pupil and parents.
Monitoring and assessment are important aspects of working towards QTS. Using assessment to inform planning (S3.2.1), report on pupils progress accurately and informatively (S3.2.7), and to review pupils progress towards learning objectives or national assessment criteria are important aspects of teaching (S3.2.3). My own assessment strategies demonstrate my commitment to raising the achievements of pupils as I work towards QTS.
3. See Appendices 3, 4 and 5.
ENGLISH AS AN ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE
In this section you should record the ways in which both the school and the subject department/curriculum area address the needs of pupils for whom English is an additional language. You should make clear reference to school policy, systems of support and subject/curriculum area practice.
I have decided to focus on the EAL provision at Heartlands, as the school has a high focus on EAL due to the ethnic make-up of the Nechells area of Birmingham. The school has many children from abroad and British-born pupils that also speak English as an additional language. The EAL coordinator, working with eight other members of staff in the EAL team, was asked by myself to summarise the aims of the EAL provision in school. The EAL co-ordinator stated that the school is ‘committed to providing a learning environment that takes into consideration our pupils’ culture, community and home language, in order to maximise the potential of all our students regardless of sex, ethnicity or country of birth.’
When a newly arrived pupil from abroad begins induction, the school aims to identify pupils’ language needs immediately and effectively, through assessment. Pupils’ language needs are worked on in the language base. When the EAL coordinator is satisfied with progress, the pupils are transferred to a part-time regular timetable of classes initially and useful information is shared with teaching staff, as are strategies for support. This is done to support pupils’ language needs in the classroom so they can have access to a broad and balanced education. Pupils with language needs are regularly monitored to ensure they are progressing. Staff can access information regarding EAL pupils through several different avenues. These include the EAL register (see Appendix 6), currently available on the ‘common area’ of the school’s intranet as a read-only document, while ILPs are also available on the common area and are updated for staff on a regular
basis. Independent learning is encouraged in order for pupils to successfully overcome language needs. Assessment is carried out through appropriate testing by the EAL team. The assessment information is broken down into four stages. These are as follows:
Step 1:
New to English
Step 2
Understand basic instructions
Level 1 (Threshold)
Understand/respond appropriately to straightforward comments or instructions
Level 1 (Secure)
Listen with understanding to sequences of instructions and usually respond appropriately
After consultation with my mentor, we highlighted that a number of recently inducted French-speaking pupils from sub-Saharan Africa, all of whom had limited English skills and identified as Step 1 or Step 2 pupils, could benefit from teaching and learning using their mother tongue. Due to the multi-cultural area the school is located within, there were already many Somali, Urdu, and Punjabi speaking staff as well as other pupils at the school to help children with English language issues who count one of these languages as the mother tongue. Recent immigration into the Nechells area has brought an influx of French-speaking Africans, many of whom have little or no English skills, but the school could not offer the same level of provision due to the lack of staff able to effectively communicate with these pupils. In coordination with the SENCO and the EAL coordinator, it was agreed that the lack of French speaking staff at the school to aid these recently inducted pupils from the Congo was believed to be hindering their educational and personal development, and impacting, to a certain extent, on staff through consequent behavioural issues due to the inability to do the work set. (Kyriacou 1991, Capel et al 1995)
Further consultation led to the conclusion that it would beneficial to have someone who can demonstrate that they can value these pupils’ first language, communicating with and teaching pupils on a whole-class and individual basis effectively by explaining and answering questions in French. In coordination with SENCO and the EAL adviser, 9 pupils from years 7 to 10 were either extracted from their usual lesson or transferred from the language lab on Mondays at 11.30 to take part in a 12 week functional English development programme that aimed to provide them with a basic toolbox to communicate in English both inside and outside the classroom.
As a qualified TESOL tutor and almost fluent French speaker, I devised a 12 lesson scheme of work that aimed to provide pupils with basic functional English, delivered by myself, to some extent, in their first language. My current mentor thought it would be more beneficial for a teacher who could show that they value pupils’ first language to work with these newly-arrived pupils, providing them with some sort of familiarity in an unfamiliar place. There was significant differentiation in terms of first language use on an individual level depending on the ability of the pupil. A variety of activities were constructed, focusing on improving reading, writing, and speaking and listening by using resources that cater for pupils with different learning styles incorporating both the target language and pupils’ first language in order to maximise understanding. These activities were purposeful, challenging and motivating.
Weekly-formative assessment marks were recorded based on pupils’ effort in written work and classroom contribution with an effort grade also being awarded. A seating plan was carefully implemented in order to enable pupils of higher ability in terms of English skills to aid and explain the activities to weaker pupils, while also taking into account pupils year group and sex. This was particularly effective in paired conversational practice and collaborative written work with the more able being able to correct the weaker pupil and explain any mistakes in their shared first language. Summative assessment was conducted after six weeks with pupils completing a printed project on themselves using ICT, focusing on reading and writing. Further summative assessment included pupils giving a presentation on an allocated e-pal in week nine to test their speaking and listening. Pupils also completed a functional language assessment to test comprehension and production of language they might encounter in the school classroom at the end of the 12-week course.
The scheme of work comprised topics such as: learning how to communicate with others in English about themselves and other people, hobbies and interests, other countries and the weather, family and pets, opinions, and classroom terminology with key word vocabulary lists being distributed each lesson and pupils tested the following week to check retention and to a certain extent to promote semi- independent learning of the target language. In week two, pupils were allocated a carefully-selected e-pal from somewhere in the world, taking a lesson to send an email to their e-pal about themselves and their hobbies, (a topic which they had focused on in week one.) These e-pals were selected and assigned to each pupil according to age, sex and screened to evaluate their ability in terms of English communication and suitability for each individual pupil. The e-pals were located in countries such as the U.S, Sweden, the Netherlands, Greece, Turkey and South Africa and, importantly, did not share the same first language as the pupils, ensuring English as the common language.
As a different topic area was taught and learnt week by week, pupils were set homework tasks to question their e-pals on the new information they had absorbed, using new vocabulary and language they had just acquired, in order to build up a profile of their e-pal with a view to completing their presentation. For example, the lesson in week five involved learning about how to talk about what pupils did last weekend and what they will be doing the forthcoming weekend. Homework was set to independently question their e-pal on this specific topic area, with pupils being informed that this information would form part of the criteria for assessment in their presentation. Promoting independent learning in this way proved successful, with pupils seemingly regularly exchanging correspondence with their e-pal, and to some extent, independently developing their own English reading and writing skills by this frequent online communication in the intended target language. This allowed me to work towards the relevant Qualifying To Teach Standard
I was also able to work with these pupils outside of the allocated period each week too. During afternoon registration (14.35 – 15.00) every day, I was fortunate enough to be able to be involved in a scheme devised by the English department called ‘Buddy Reading.’ Taking place in the school library, English teachers and support staff would, on an individual level, sit with pupils who would read aloud a book of their choice pupils with reading issues of all different backgrounds, cultures and ages. This aimed to promote reading for pleasure and with the help of their ‘buddy reader’, pupils could practise and improve their reading skills. These pupils would be excused from afternoon registration and all of the French-speaking pupils were already taking part as part of the induction process.
This time afforded me the opportunity to develop their reading skills, consuming less-demanding, accessible children’s books as a group, with pupils reading in turn, and myself using their first language to check comprehension and explain aspects of language or vocabulary. The scheme also allowed me to spend time with the pupils each day as they were assimilated into school life. I was therefore able to build supportive, successful relationships with the English learners, which brought a comfortable atmosphere into each subsequent lesson and enabled a positive and fun learning environment to thrive. This scheme also presented me with the opportunity to further enhance their target language development and aid their assimilation into life in a new school and a new country while working towards a Qualifying To Teach Standard (S3.3.5)
To establish a more effective communicative link between these pupils and the EAL team, I set up of an email address englishhw@hotmail.co.uk where pupils could send any issues or concerns in their first language about work or school life. This proved productive, as due to a busy timetable, I was unavailable to translate for pupils individually and any problems at school could be quickly conveyed using the schools computers in the library. The EAL term commented on this being an innovative scheme, which has proved successful in rapidly helping pupils with any concerns. I even set up an online link to notify me of any emails from the specific pupils by text message to my mobile phone, effectively using ICT to aid communication between these newly arrived pupils and staff. The text message system allowed a very rapid response. The facility was welcomed by the pupils and was certainly not
abused in any way whatsoever, providing a stronger supporting link between the newly-arrived pupils and the staff.
In other classes, subject teachers are provided with information from the EAL register, which is available to all staff via the ‘common area’ on the school’s intranet system. Pupils that are transferred from the language lab to regular timetabled lessons are accompanied with detailed information that can be accessed by all their subject teachers via the intranet. This is shown in the EAL register. (see Appendix 6) Teachers could then, for example, know to give extra individual support to that pupil, or possibly use extra adult support in lessons to give guidance in pupils first language to a certain extent, circumstances permitting.
Subject teachers continually liaise with the EAL team to provide a variety of learning support and monitor the progress of pupils on the register. An example of a page from the register is attached with a key to decipher acronyms for pupils needs. This register helps to inform all subject teachers in their planning and to build support techniques into their lessons, recognising an important whole-school issue at Heartlands.
There is also a fledgling adult literacy scheme for parents of pupils at the school with EAL needs. This is in an early developmental stage and is a concept that I intend to become involved in should I successfully be appointed at the school.
THE KEY STAGE THREE STRATEGY
In consultation with your mentor you should identify and record:
1. The four strands of the Key Stage Three Strategy and how these are managed in school.
2. The particular approaches that have been adopted to enable:
- the raising of pupil expectation
- progression from Key Stage Two to Key Stage Three,
- the development of teaching and learning strategies
- improved pupil motivation
The Key Stage 3 National Strategy is a programme, which is non-statutory and began in September 2001 that aims to raise standards by strengthening teaching and learning across the curriculum for all 11 to 14 year olds. It is based on four main principles: the raising of expectations for all pupils and setting challenging targets for them to achieve, strengthening progression and transition from key stage 2 and developing progression throughout key stage 3, providing opportunities for all pupils to benefit from a range of teaching approaches and contexts to unlock their motivation, and setting up a programme of professional development and practical support to strengthen teaching and learning. (www.qca.org.uk) The Key Stage 3 Strategy consists of strands covering English, mathematics, science, information and communication technology (ICT) and the other foundation subjects, including modern foreign languages (MFL) and design and technology. Secondary schools, therefore, are provided with an exciting and challenging opportunity to build on the successes of the National Literacy and Numeracy Strategies in primary education.
Since 2001, when the school was almost put into Special Measures by Ofsted Inspectors, my mentor has commented that the Headteacher has strived to improve standards across the curriculum, liaising closely with the English and Maths department as the Key Stage 3 Strategy is followed.
The school seems to have implemented key aspects of the Strategy effectively. Teachers at the school welcome the training and other support the Strategy provides and many are enthused by the developments it seems. Recent observation of lessons by Ofsted at the end of February 2006, and scrutiny of pupils’ work indicate that the Strategy is having an increasing effect on pupils’ attainment at Heartlands. Results in the national tests in have improved, most significantly in mathematics and in the proportion of pupils achieving higher levels in science. Overall, it seems that the number of schools achieving the DfES floor targets in the core subjects at Key Stage 3 has also risen significantly. The Strategy is helping to improve teaching across the school, my mentor commented. The use of specific objectives for learning and better planning have added greater purpose and challenge to many lessons since September 2001. The English Department has reviewed schemes of work in line with the Strategy frameworks and guidance and my mentor has commented on how other departments have followed suit. Improvements in teaching have led to better attitudes to work, especially, but not only, among boys.
The Headteacher has taken a particular interest in assessment across the curriculum. Heads of Department submit exercise books to the Headteacher on a regular basis to check for consistency in marking across the curriculum, with a particular focus on literacy.
The impact of the Strategy is certainly being felt in the English department at the school. After observing lessons with a number of teachers within the department, the vast majority of those observed lessons followed the relevant structure as established within the strategy, but my mentor voiced concern that there is little consolidation of literacy skills in other subject lessons, with issues of consistency across the curriculum attempting to be addressed by the current Head of Department. Nevertheless, ICT use within English lessons is increasing and is having a The Strategy has brought important benefits in terms of attainment in mathematics at the school. The benefits tend to be greater for higher-attaining than for lower-attaining pupils. The organisation and teaching of catch-up programmes continues to be a problem, with under half the pupils involved progressing to level 4 during Year 7. The use of ICT in the teaching of mathematics remains a focus for senior management, with the majority of Maths rooms being equipped with ICT facilities. Ongoing training by a member of the maths department is helping teachers of subjects across the curriculum. There is also practical action to improve the use of numeracy across the curriculum led by the head of the maths department.
Well-structured schemes of work and the encouraging of teachers to be more specific in setting objectives and more flexible in the activities they use have resonated successfully in the Science department. In foundation subjects such as French, which I was involved in sporadically, learning skills are developing, notably in oral work, research and collaborative working, with pair and group work a regular feature and increasing ICT use being used effectively in well-structured lessons. This is having a positive impact on pupils’ attitudes, among boys in particular
In terms of ICT, the school is continuing to progress by adding an extra ICT suite to boost the school’s provision, while training for staff in this area is continually focused upon with inset development sessions a regular occurrence.
Aspects of transition from primary to secondary school within the Nechells Action Zone are currently in development. A senior member of staff is forging stronger links with primary schools in a bid to successfully transfer information and data about pupils. Curriculum continuity remains a key focus
for the school, as there is still much to do to enable more pupils to make appropriate progress from the start of their secondary education, it was acknowledged, and this is the reason for the implementation of this new programme. Strategies such as inviting potential pupils and parents to open days at the school, and sessions to acclimatise primary pupils to secondary school by allowing them to spend a day within the school are particular approaches adopted by the school.
In conclusion, aspects of the Key Stage 3 National Strategy and it’s successful implementation since 2001 has allowed the school, to a certain extent, to move from the brink of special measures to being a good and improving school as Ofsted noted after inspection in February 2006.
You Should:
1. Create opportunities to observe teaching in a range of subjects and
contexts.
2. Record your observations identifying the range of teaching strategies
employed in lessons e.g. whole class, group work, pair work etc.
I have observed a range of lessons across the curriculum, each using a variety of different teaching strategies, based around the Key Stage 3 National Strategy. In the majority of lessons, a range of different teaching and learning strategies were employed by teachers at the school.
In French lessons that I observed, for example, there was a huge range in the strategies used. Pupils would typically be involved in pair work at least once a lesson to try to improve their language practice. Whole class work would usually be used by the teacher for the repetition of new vocabulary, while the practising of this new vocabulary, in terms of oral work, would be done in pairs. There was an absence of group work in French lessons which was noticeable though, as writing tasks were predominantly individual.
History lessons that I observed used collaborative strategies the least. The majority of work was done either as a whole class or on an individual basis, with paired or group work largely absent. This is something that could be addressed as the nature of the subject does not mean that collaborative work is out of the question. Further collaborative work could lead to enhanced pupil enjoyment of the lessons and help pupils to make progress.
At the school, there is also an Integrated Studies (I.S) Programme, which fuses elements of English, ICT, History, and Geography. The I.S lessons I observed used pair work and group work successfully with pupils completing group projects on whales and dolphins. The pupils seemed to enjoy these lessons very much, using ICT and collaboration to complete objective-led activities.
Observing strategies used in other lessons allows teachers to be reflective about their own lessons. Viewing successful pair work in French lessons and group work in I.S lessons, has allowed me to reflect on my own teaching strategies in terms of helping pupils to progress.
POST-16 EDUCATION
Where possible you should discuss with your mentor approaches to learning and teaching in your subject/curriculum area in the post-16 phase.
In this section you should record the following:
1. School policy and practice in relation to post-16 progression
Despite only being revised in September, the Heartlands High school’s new fledgling post 16 education provision is continually expanding. The school has no sixth form provision itself but is fully committed to providing a transition for pupils that want to continue into further education.
The leader of the programme, in conjunction with Connexions, runs a scheme centred around a careers room based on the third floor of the school. This room contains information on future careers or FE options for the school’s pupils and visiting Connexions staff are regularly available for discussions with pupils. The room is open from 8.00 to 8.30 and 12.40 to 13.20 each day. Pupils have the opportunity to view prospecti, talk to the adviser or use the computers to engage in interactive career-focused activities of the Kudos program. This program is designed to allow pupils to explore avenues to their selected careers in an engaging way. Year 11 recently used the software to prepare themselves in writing college applications. The software, and indeed the scheme itself, is not entirely geared towards more senior pupils as Year 7s are very welcome, with the coordinator of the provision commenting that it is important for pupils to be involved early in their development.
The school believes it is important to fully prepare pupils intending on going to college with a successful transition, not only in the quality of education provided. For example, pupils in Year 10 had to prepare in March for mock college interviews with a member of staff from the school. These practice interviews were conducted in private, on a one-to-one basis with pupils marked on their performance and preparation. Individual feedback was provided in order to fully equip and prepare pupils for real-life college interviews.
Since I have been at the school, Year 10 have visited both Aston University and Matthew Boulton College, institutions which have forged good links with the school, in educational expeditions designed to help them to explore future options.
Pupils in Year 11 are also provided with a ‘mentor’ from nearby Aston University. The pupils meet their mentor on a regular basis to discuss further education and higher education options, again aiming to provide pupils with a successful transition from the school to other institutions.
In discussion with the Post 16 Programme leader, it was established that, while a small percentage of pupils, upon leaving the school, begin Work Based Learning schemes or employment-focused training, over half begin FE courses.
Destination data (see Appendix 7) shows while those entering sixth forms in 2003 was at nearly 30%, this dropped to only 6.5% in 2005. Compare this to the explosion of those entering further education through college courses, which rose from just over 35% in 2003 to over 55% in 2004. FE courses again accounted for over half of all pupils leaving in 2005. Consistently, those entering WBL schemes or apprenticeships has remained at around 10% since 2003. Around 12% of pupils on leaving, on average, are discounted statistically due to circumstances arising immediately after leaving the school such as pregnancy or custodial sentencing. (see Appendix 8).
This data seems to reinforce the programme leader’s view that the most popular courses now include BTECS in subjects such as health and social care and sports studies, with the more traditionally academically gifted pupils taking A-Levels. The most popular destinations include the local Matthew Boulton College, South Birmingham College, City College, Solihull College and Sutton Coldfield College.
My mentor has commented on how the implementation of a new Media Studies GCSE, through the English department, may provide pupils with more options in terms of FE from September 2006. Media aspects of the current English GCSE are very popular and when I questioned year 11 pupils, they were overwhelmingly enthusiastic about Media Studies, with some pupils deciding that it would be a subject they would be certainly interested in pursuing in FE, but the lack of a GCSE in this area is somewhat hindering FE progress, something that my current mentor as head of the English department is seeking to address. With the birth of the Media Studies GCSE in September 2006 at the school, this may provide some with another path to further education.
2. Your understanding of the post-16 qualifications framework
“At present the system does well by a proportion of young people who are engaged and motivated by conceptual study. It does much less well by those whose preferences are for learning which is more practical, with an obvious relevance and application to the wider world”.
(DFES, 2005, p21)
My understanding of this statement is that currently, the problems lie in terms of providing options for not only a successful academic path but more so for those more vocationally-minded pupils in post-compulsory education. This is relevant at the Heartlands school as the majority of leavers do not follow on to A-Levels but instead choose more vocational subjects or Work Based Learning schemes.
While there is some evidence that the National Literacy and Numeracy Strategies have successfully increased standards, especially for boys, the need to reform post compulsory education is based on the view that too few young people persist in education beyond the age of 16 and they leave schools with a low grasp of basic skills. One element of the government’s strategy has been to offer cash inducements to stay on after 16 through the Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA). This policy was introduced nationally in September 2004 and involves a regular weekly payment to young people from disadvantaged backgrounds as an incentive to remain in post-compulsory education. The Education Maintenance Allowance appears to have increased staying on rates for low-income pupils and this has had a particular impact on those leaving Heartlands High School as the majority of pupils are from low socio-economic backgrounds. One reason for the high dropout rates though may be the lack of good vocational options and this is having an adverse effect on the economy of the UK.
It seems that there is a gap between leaving education and being fully prepared for employment and compared to our economic competitors around the world. The post compulsory education system in the UK suffers from low participation and a narrow curriculum with the dropout rate after 16 much higher than other countries and a large proportion of people with poor basic skills compared to other nations.
The Tomlinson report, which was largely rejected by the government, resulted in Ruth Kelly’s 14-19 White Paper which stopped short of abolishing GCSEs and A-Levels but aimed to strengthen vocational education and widen opportunity for all young people. A new diploma to recognise those who achieve five GCSEs, grades A* to C or equivalent, including Maths and English, will be introduced. Specialised diplomas will be made available in 14 subject areas, reflecting key sectors of the economy, to boost vocational qualifications. These can be taken by pupils aged 14. All students will need to achieve at least a grade C in Maths and English to pass their diploma. The first four subject areas will be available from 2008, the remainder by 2015. The government has also drawn up plans for 200 vocationally led schools that will be established by 2008 along with 12 skills academies.
The number of assessed A-level modules will be reduced from six to four, although the overall content will not change. More challenging questions and a 4,000-word dissertation will be introduced for the brightest students. Sixth-formers will also be able to study university modules. Universities will have access to the individual module grades achieved in A-levels to distinguish between the brightest students.
Ministers have failed, however, in their promise to reform the 14-19 curriculum and created a "rag-bag" of changes by rejecting the findings of the Tomlinson inquiry, England's General Teaching Council said in April 2005. It said the Government had missed an opportunity to revise the qualifications process, in particular to make it more equitable for low-achievers. In a draft response to the 14-19 education and skills white paper, the council backed plans for greater support for key stage 3 pupils performing below Level 5 in core subjects. It was critical, however, of the failure to raise the status of vocational qualifications, the "narrowness" of the proposed new diploma and the lack of emphasis on teacher assessment. There was also a lack of alignment with the Government's Every Child Matters policy, which promoted greater cooperation between education, health and social services, it said. (TES, 22 April 2005)
In terms of my own subject area, GCSE English will be redesigned to make it impossible to get a C without having mastered "functional" aspects of the subjects, said the paper. But there will be no basic English or Maths exams, as Tomlinson wanted. The impact on the English curriculum may be that the subject moves more towards a syllabus of teaching more functional English that can be used practically as opposed to the literary heritage-dominated model that currently stands. This will change not only what is taught but also how it is taught, to some extent, as teachers aim to provide all learners in English with these basic functional skills in preparation for further education and future employment. ICT will undoubtedly become increasingly more important too within the subject area.
INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY
You should seek opportunities to develop the use of ICT in your own teaching.
You should observe at least one lesson using ICT which could be in a subject other than your own.
Record your findings/observation below:
I observed a year 7 mixed-ability English lesson focusing on the literacy priorities of spelling, punctuation and comprehension of text. The lesson, delivered by an NQT, used ICT effectively as a tool to enhance both teaching and learning. The activities in the lesson tested the key skills of reading, writing and speaking and listening, with ICT used to contribute to the lesson in a variety of ways.
Using the four-part lesson plan, the teacher began by handing out worksheets that contained relevant ability material. The worksheet contained a short passage, with punctuation errors and capital letters missing, about a boy’s trip to the beach, entitled ‘Abed's Special Day’. It is clear that the teacher used Microsoft Word to produce the worksheet which used a large Comic Sans font, with key instructions in bold, and text boxes used to separate tasks to good effect. The worksheet and the instructions written on it, coupled with verbal instructions were clear and simple. The teacher then clearly read aloud the short passage to the class. After using open questioning and Microsoft PowerPoint to explain learning objectives and to check pupils’ knowledge and understanding of where commas, full stops and capital letters are correctly used, pupils were allowed to edit the worksheet individually inserting capital letters and punctuation where they deemed it
necessary. After the allocated time to complete the task, the teacher displayed the unedited worksheet on the IAW and invited pupils to individually use the green IAW pen and write a correction which they made on their worksheet on the display. Pupils responded well and were keen on coming to the front and displaying their ideas on the IAW, with the teacher using open questioning to check understanding.
When the displayed text had been sufficiently edited, pupils were set to work to complete comprehension questions relating to the passage in their exercise books. This writing exercise tested their reading for meaning capabilities and again the pupils worked individually and remained on task to a large extent. The IAW was then used to display the questions, providing a multi-sensory environment for different learning styles. After the time limit had expired, the majority of pupils had completed the nearly all of the questions and some had progressed onto the extension task of writing about their own special day, using the past tense. The teacher then enforced a hands-up rule in order to question pupils in a whole class discussion about their responses to the comprehension questions about the passage.
As a plenary, again the IAW was used and pupils were involved in an interactive game of ‘Who Wants To Be A Millionaire’, testing not general knowledge, but their comprehension of the passage and spelling, punctuation and grammar issues contained within in, as well as more generic questions with regard to capital letters and full stops. Again a hands-up rule was envoked by the teacher, and pupils were invited to come to the IAW and touch the screen to display their chosen answer. Pupils clearly enjoyed this activity and combined with further questioning, this helped to further develop pupils understanding of literacy priorities explored during the lesson. This proved to be an effective plenary as all pupils wanted to take part, undaunted by the questions displayed on screen in a way that possibly would not be displayed in other types of plenary.
I discussed the lesson with the NQT that devised and delivered it in order to evaluate the use of ICT in the lesson and my findings with my current mentor at Heartlands school.
Record your notes of the school-based discussion below:
In order to achieve QTS, a teacher must demonstrate that they are capable and competent in terms of ICT (S2.5, S3.3.10). Teachers must show that they know how to use it effectively within the subject, including planning for the use of ICT, and delivering lessons using ICT. One of the biggest mistakes, however, when using ICT is when its use does not support the learning, the presumption being that just because ICT is being used, it is appropriate. (Ellis et al 2002) It was agreed in discussion that the observed lesson did not follow this principle and that the way in which ICT was used directly contributed to the learning of literacy priorities.
It was worth noting that the NQT whose lesson I observed had, on the 24th March, involved herself in an after school, cross-curricular training inset run in conjunction with the ICT department to help teachers use Interactive Whiteboards effectively. This ongoing technologically-minded professional development is crucial to 21st century teacher, it would seem.
Firstly, in terms of production of the worksheets using ICT, the teacher explained the importance of using certain clear fonts, as well as a large type and bold font to illustrate key words or instructions, with text boxes to separate tasks. These are skills which have influenced the way I produce worksheets, after consultation with the SENCO too. Clearly, ICT can somewhat lighten a teachers workload.
Using Microsoft PowerPoint to display examples on the IAW and strategic, open questioning allowed the pupils to refresh their knowledge of capital letters and punctuation. This is something that could have been done using the regular whiteboard, it was noted, but the visual excitement of colours and pictures I believe stimulated the pupils further. Using PowerPoint in this interactive way also allowed the teacher to easily access the examples and questions in order to promote understanding. This would take time to write on the board carefully and would, to some extent, disrupt the pace of the lesson from the outset. This demonstrates that using ICT in this way lightens the teacher’s workload and can contribute to dictating the pace of lessons.
My mentor commented that the starter task could have benefited from making use of pair work to edit the worksheets. This seems logical as it may have further improved understanding as pupils would be discussing the task and learning from one another. The down side of this may be that some pupils cannot work as a pair, or this could result in extra classroom management issues adversely affecting collective learning.
Pupils clearly enjoyed the interactivity of writing on the IAW but my mentor again advised caution when selecting pupils to participate in this activity. Nevertheless, it was clearly a very motivating and worthwhile exercise that focused pupils clearly towards learning objectives and literacy priorities.
I believe that this was the most effective way of allowing the pupils to demonstrate their ideas to the whole class, thus reinforcing collective understanding and supporting learning. Giving all pupils a visual display of corrections written by their peers using the IAW is a most effective way and conducting this activity. This could have been done on an OHP, it was commented on, but clearly the method using the IAW as a tool for teaching and learning enabled pupils to interact and learn in an innovative way that they found exciting.
Displaying the comprehension questions visually on the IAW as well as providing them on the worksheets, ensures a multi-sensory learning environment for pupils too.
In terms of a plenary, my mentor agreed that the ‘Who Wants To Be A Millionaire’ game was of a high standard, reinforcing what pupils had learnt in the lesson in a fun and interactive way. In this instance, using ICT to aid a plenary proved most beneficial, as pupils clearly enjoyed the task. A different, more traditional plenary of hot seating, for example, may not have brought the same level of response and enthusiasm from pupils and not reinforce the knowledge and understanding acquired during the lesson as effectively or end the lesson in such a positive, enthusiastic manner.
It is clear that using ICT as a tool for teaching and learning in this lesson helped to lighten the teacher’s workload, motivate and engage pupils and reinforce and support understanding and progress towards specific literacy-based learning objectives.
PASTORAL CARE
You should work as a pair. You should look at one case study (see page 24-25) and should approach those staff whom you think would be able to help you to deal with the situation for information and guidance. You should come prepared to share the information you have collected with the rest of the group.
Record your findings below:
Case Study B:
Shebana is in Year 8. She is always quiet and well-behaved, smartly dressed, conscientious, hard working, does her homework. She is brought to school by her parents. She is a bit of a loner but has one or two close friends. Yesterday she missed a lesson. Today she missed registration arriving late and upset at having to sign in at the office. She sits on her own. The school secretary mentions to her form tutor that she was upset. At break in the staff room, other teachers mention her unusual behaviour.
In consultation with the form tutor whose group I am currently attached to at the Heartlands high school, there was a range of strategies discussed with a view to discovering the reasons for Shebana’s uncharacteristic behaviour. What was certainly agreed was that any approach made, either directly to the pupil concerned or to her close friends at the school, would have to be both sensitive and tactful. It was also noted that the form tutor might want to speak to some of Shebana’s teachers as to whether they have noticed any changes in her behaviour, manner, or approach within their lessons. This could provide some clues as to Shebana’s issues and should possibly be done before approaching the pupil directly or questioning her friends.
It is clear that this pupil is displaying some uncharacteristic behaviour. This could be for any number of reasons. It is important to try to establish the reason for this behaviour in order to help the individual pupil concerned. The form tutor could either approach Shebana’s close friends in private to try to ascertain if they know whether anything has happened to upset Shebana, or directly approach the pupil to determine whether there are any problems either within school or even at home.
Shebana is brought to school every day by her parents, it was noted, and is used to this routine. A break in this structure would indicate there to be a possible issue at home or outside of school and it is therefore important to speak tactfully and sensitively to the pupil concerned in private.
Whether the pupil would open up is another matter and would not only depend on the manner in which this is approached, but to some extent, which teacher approaches the pupil. Pupils are sometimes more responsive to teachers they feel they can trust and a female teacher is possibly more likely to be prompt Shebana into talking about any issues which she feels she may not be able to discuss with a male teacher.
It is important this situation is resolved as soon as possible so that these concerns have no longer-term impact in the educational or personal development of the child involved.
In this instance, a heavy handed punishment from the form tutor for missing a lesson or for tardiness should not be dealt out as there appear to be extenuating circumstances for the uncharacteristic behaviour of Shebana.
After successfully speaking to the pupil involved and ascertaining the reasons for this uncharacteristic behaviour, the form tutor could consult with possibly the head of year to follow up these concerns. This may involve the school contacting parents or speaking to Shebana's friends to monitor the situation closely.
It was agreed in discussion that it is important that teachers use their individual discretion, and tact to identify concerns or factors affecting the child concerned and successfully help any pupils with any circumstances that are affecting their educational and personal development. An effective system of support should be in place within the school to address any concerns identified with senior management playing a crucial role in helping pupils to overcome any problems inside or outside school which affect their well-being by being an effective link between home and school.
PRACTICAL EXPERIENCE OF PASTORAL CARE:
Attachment to form tutor (required):
Year 7 Name of class 7S (Holyhead)
Year 8 Name of class 8THN (Heartlands)
Record briefly your involvement with tutorial work:
During both of my school experiences I have been involved within the pastoral system, being attached to a form group at each school. Both of the form tutors I was attached to had differing pedagogical approaches, methodology and ideas about their roles as pastoral carers. At Holyhead, a very discipline-centred approach by an experienced, senior male English teacher contrasted to the more relaxed attitude of a young female Maths NQT at the Heartlands High School. Both tutors, as well as myself, were responsible for a form of mixed ability pupils, seeing them twice as a group each day.
The way registration was conducted in both instances had similarities and differences. At Holyhead, an electronic register was conducted both at morning and afternoon registration, with the e-register containing detailed pupil information while at Heartlands a more traditional, clerical approach was used. At both schools, a regular daily bulletin was announced by the form tutor, giving pupils useful information about the day while a full equipment check was conducted habitually. Differences in terms of the teacher approach to their role somewhat reflected the character of the individual teacher involved but were also impacted upon by administrative procedures and facilities.
At Holyhead the teacher expected total silence at the start of registration with pupils’ uniform suitably amended before entering the form room, with latecomers harshly disciplined. A regular review of the previous days ‘Form Diary’ was conducted each day, with subject teachers comments about the form’s collective performance, including the singling-out of individuals mentioned by name for whatever reason, commented on by the form tutor himself. Pupils could be publicly commended due to subject teachers comments in the ‘Form Diary’ or suitably disciplined. This system allowed the form tutor to be very much aware of and involved in their form’s and individual pupils' progress on a daily basis. This proved an essential tool for the form tutor to effectively report to parents when necessary. The form tutor was able to therefore act as a strong link between subject teachers and parents in discipline issues as individual concerns could be closely monitored due to the ‘Form Diary’ system. On regular occasion, the form tutor would contact parents after continuing discipline problems with individuals, initially identified through the ‘Form Diary’, while it provides the basis for the form tutors comments for a parents evening.
The form tutor would also use the registration periods to verbally reinforce his own and the school’s expectations, while ensuring that each and every registration period ended on a positive note with either one of the pupils or teachers present telling a joke. It is clear that the tutor had forged strong relationships with the year 7 pupils and made full use of the systems in place such as the form diary and the e-register to be fully involved in pupils progression and development, while using the allocated periods to maintain a positive and disciplined atmosphere in conjunction with school and his own expectations to prepare pupils for the challenges of the school day.
With 8NTH at Heartlands, pupils arrived haphazardly, not being disciplined as harshly as at Holyhead. Pupil punctuality seems to remain a whole-school problem for subject teachers and form tutors at the school. Expectations of uniform were reinforced by the form tutor, with pupils being consistently reminded to remove their non-regulation jackets. The form tutors approach meant that pupils were allowed to talk to one another quietly until the teacher decided to call the register or announce the daily bulletin. The tutor explained this social-approach mentioning that it was important for the pupils to build successful relationships with their peers within the form context. As there is no ‘Form Diary’ system present at Heartlands, the form tutor remains somewhat unaware of collective or individual concerns in specific lessons or with specific subject teachers, while more serious concerns are usually passed on to the Head of Year. This could possibly hinder form tutors efforts to effectively and thoroughly report on their pupils when required. This gap in knowledge of pupils performances in subject areas or issues of concern forced me to reflect on the more administrative nature of my experience of the pastoral system at Heartlands, compared to my experience at Holyhead. The form tutors role seemed to centre around administrative tasks such as the register and the bulletin, with the Head of Year acting as the link between parents and the school somewhat more than the form tutor. This is not the result of the individual teachers approach but more due to the school systems in place that do not provide form tutors with the easily accessible detailed pupil information or regular comment from subject teachers about the forms performance as at Holyhead.
Both school experiences provided different challenges and demands in terms of pastoral care and it was extremely useful to compare two differing approaches and two different school administrative systems in order to evaluate the effectiveness of each approach and system.
B. Attendance at parents evening (where possible):
Date: November 30th 2005 (Holyhead School), March 17th 2006 (Heartlands High School)
Notes:.
I have been fortunate enough to be involved in two different methods of reporting to parents during my two school experiences. Towards the end of my placement at Holyhead in Handsworth, I was involved in a Year 9 parents evening, where as a subject teacher I was able to comment on the performances of my English group in the allocated five minute slot. The session began at 17.30 and ran until 20.00 with most pupils being in time for their allocated slot and this was somewhat strictly enforced. The turn out was around 75% which slightly improved on the previous parents evening for these pupils at the end of year 8. The organisation of the event allowed for two-way discussions, with parents being able to ask detailed subject-specific questions with regard to their child to the teacher of any subject, and with the teacher being able to discuss, in detail, any particular areas for concern within the subject. It also allowed parents to view examples of their child’s work in each subject and liaise closer with subject teachers to take collaborative action in any specific subjects or areas where the pupil has weaknesses.
Allowing parents to communicate to each of their child’s subject teachers directly and consecutively has distinct advantages it seems. It affords the parents the scope to identify, from a range of discussions, just how their child is performing at school and each individual meeting raises new questions for them, depending what they are told and how it is communicated by the teacher. Vietnamese, Punjabi, Somali and Urdu translators for some pupils’ parents had been organised and were rotated extremely efficiently, allowing parents from all backgrounds to involve themselves in direct dialogue with each subject teacher. The parents though, were not given a written summary or grade in terms of their child’s performance in each subject, meaning they had only the teachers’ verbal comments and nothing in writing to take away and reflect on. Written reports would arrive in their hands nearly two weeks later, but closer coordination in the two reporting processes may have proved more beneficial in the long term in terms of helping parents to effectively communicate with school staff and participate in their child’s development. If the parents received reports days before the parents evening, for example, they could think of questions or issues to raise with particular teachers.
At Heartlands school in Nechells, I was involved in a different capacity in Year 7 review day. At this event, parents met with form tutors to discuss their child's cross-curricular performance. As I was not involved in the Year 7 pastoral system, I volunteered to translate for newly arrived Congalese pupils in year 7 and their parents who would speak little English it was anticipated. This enabled me to see the reporting procedure from a different perspective. There was no detailed subject specific discussion but form tutors used the allocated 15 minutes to attempt to outline and identify any areas for improvement through subject teachers comments on the ‘review form’ which was only presented to parents when they sat down. Parents could question form tutors on subject teachers comment and grades but any concerns they had could not be directly addressed. The form tutors could only assure parents they would pass on these concerns but this indirect link left some parents disillusioned it seems. In this method of reporting, there was no direct dialogue with subject teachers, only an indirect link through the form tutor and pastoral system. In my role as a translator, I was able to communicate what the form tutors would explain to parents in terms of their child's report form, but I was also able to judge their quiet disappointment and to some extent open frustration at not being able to speak directly to individual subject teachers – particularly in subjects where their child is seemingly performing poorly.
Not being able to address these subject specific concerns seemed a persistent problem, with many of the Congalese parents asking questions that their child’s form tutor could not answer, while being assured that the form tutor would contact the teacher involved to give them an answer. As the parents had limited English skills, this would surely impact on any future contact the form tutor were to have with them regarding answers to questions voiced at the review day. Parents were given a written report though containing a comment and grade to take away with them. This could have been translated into their first language for those parents with English issues, but this was not the case, possibly leaving some parents slightly overwhelmed and confused. A slightly smaller turnout of just over 70% on this review day was possibly due to the scheduling of the appointments throughout the day, with parents possible employment or other commitments being a factor.
Overall, I feel that the both methods of reporting to parents have provided me with different experiences and perspectives with regard to attaining Qualifying To Teach Standard (S1.4) and I have been able to evaluate both of them critically, considering their effectiveness in providing a communicative link between teachers and parents.
